Tilt for a More Dynamic Composition

May 07, 2015  •  2 Comments

In my last blog entry, I wrote about my experience shooting high school tennis. After the shoot, I also posted a few of my favorite pictures on a photography forum (the Nikon Cafe) for critique. One of the members was kind enough to offer some suggestions for improving my set of photographs.

When viewing all of these photos, you'll note that I took great pains to ensure that each frame is perfectly straight with a level horizon. The forum member suggested that I play with and add some tilt to some of the crops. Sometimes, shooting a subject on an angle makes the image more dynamic--which is particularly helpful with action shots.

I revisited some of the images and adjusted the crops. I like the affect. I also like how the treatment adds diversity to the collection of photos from the session. And, I suspect that the players will like some of the tilted shots more than my original crops!

Here's an example of two images--one with a straight horizon and the other with an intentional tilt:

Rick SmithRick SmithRick Smith of the Sandburg High School tennis team at 13300 South La Grange Road in Orland Park, Illinois on May 1, 2015 Rick SmithRick SmithRick Smith of the Sandburg High School tennis team at 13300 South La Grange Road in Orland Park, Illinois on May 1, 2015 The lessons that I learned from this are: 1) straight images are not necessarily better; and 2) be open to critique as it will likely improve my photography!


Comments

Glenn Nagel Photography
Thanks Brad...that makes perfect sense in terms of publication. All my shots from day, including the one with the intentional tilt--were all straight (no tilt) out of the camera. I added this tilt so that there would be more diversity for the parents to choose from. I still have both versions available. The tilted ones are the versions that many of the customers prefer! In any event, I think the forum member gave some helpful advice in terms of not having all the shots in my portfolio from the game look too similar. I don't take advice from a forum member until I've made an assessment that it's worth a try. In this case, I think it helped to have some different looks--in addition to the vast majority that were presented with the perfectly straight composition.
brad barr(non-registered)
Problem with that....is that quite often the one providing the "help" is not qualified and does not know what they are talking about. Every photo editor would likely dump the second one due to the horizon being tilted. IMO, what makes the second shot interesting is not the tilt, but the fact that both the racket and the ball are above the net (and thus not obscured by it). Not the fact that its tilted. Advice is fine, and everyone has opinions....problem is that when considering the merit of everyone's opinion...you really need to consider their photographic background. Just look at what gets called "amazing" on facebook posts. From what I've seen.....your eye is among the best out there....and the person that issued that advice, should probably be following your advice as opposed to you following his. ijs.
No comments posted.
Loading...

Archive
January (1) February (2) March (1) April May June July August September October November December
January February March April May June July August September October November December
January February March April May June July August September October November December
January February March April May June July August September October November December